Pull a Lucky Fish Fish Tier List — Best Catches Ranked by Rarity and Income

Whether you’re casting from the shore or venturing into the treacherous Far Water, knowing which fish are worth risking shark attacks for is the key to building your tycoon empire. In Pull a Lucky Fish by Openwater Games, every catch has a unique island income value, and rarer fish can transform your cash flow. This tier list ranks every known fish from S to C tier based on rarity, island income generation, and overall value to your progression. We’ll also break down the best strategies for hooking the most elusive species and how to maximize your earnings once you bank them.

Complete Fish Tier List

Below is the definitive ranking of every known fish in Pull a Lucky Fish. The island income stat is the passive cash generated per interval when the fish is safely stored in your aquarium, and rarer fish provide exponentially higher payouts.

S Tier — The Ultimate Catches

Voidfish (Secret) The Voidfish is the undisputed crown jewel of Pull a Lucky Fish. According to community reports, this fish has an estimated catch rate of <1%, making it the rarest species in the game. When placed on your island, it generates the highest possible passive income, outscaling every other fish by a significant margin. The Voidfish is only found in the Far Water, which means you cannot even attempt to catch it without first investing heavily in casting distance training. If you see a player return with a shimmering, dark celestial fish, you know their economy is about to skyrocket.

Prism Fish (Secret) Sharing the S tier is the Prism Fish, another Secret rarity catch. Unlike the Voidfish, the Prism Fish has been reported in multiple water depths, though it is still exceptionally rare. Its island income is listed as "Very High," and its constantly shifting colors make it a visual trophy. The Prism Fish is slightly more forgiving in its spawn conditions, but the drop rate remains brutally low. Owning both a Voidfish and a Prism Fish is the ultimate flex and essentially grants you infinite passive income.

A Tier — Mythic and Legendary Powerhouses

Alien Fish (Mythic) The Alien Fish is the sole representative of the Mythic rarity. It generates high island income and is a massive upgrade over any Epic fish. The Alien Fish is exclusively found in the Far Water, sharing its habitat with the Voidfish. While not as lucrative as the Secret tier, catching an Alien Fish is a sign that your rod and training are strong enough to compete in the endgame. Its unique green, extraterrestrial design makes it instantly recognizable.

Dolphin (Legendary) The Dolphin is a Legendary fish found in the Deep Water, which acts as a bridge between the mid-game and the Far Water. Its island income is high, and it can be caught with a mid-tier rod if you have invested in some casting distance. The Dolphin is considered the benchmark for entering the late game; if you can reliably catch Dolphins, you are ready to start pushing into the Far Water.

Sunfish (Legendary) The Sunfish shares the exact same rarity and income tier as the Dolphin. It is a massive, flat, bony fish that also spawns in the Deep Water. While functionally similar to the Dolphin in terms of income, the Sunfish is a massive, flat, bony fish that also spawns in the Deep Water. Collectors will want both, as banking a variety of rare fish diversifies your island's ecosystem and your income stream.

B Tier — The Mid-Game Economy

Codfish (Epic) The Codfish is an Epic rarity fish that you will encounter frequently in the mid-game. Its island income is notably lower than Legendary fish, but it is far easier to catch. You can find the Codfish in the Mid Water zone. For players who have just upgraded from the basic rod to something like the Ice Rod, the Codfish represents the first real taste of a functioning economy. It is not flashy, but it pays the bills.

Colorless Fish (Epic) The Colorless Fish is an interesting Epic rarity catch. As the name suggests, it lacks the vibrant colors of other fish, appearing almost translucent or grey. It provides medium island income and is found in the Mid Water. Some players initially mistake it for a Secret fish due to its unusual appearance, but it is simply an Epic. It is a solid catch for padding your aquarium while you hunt for Legendaries.

Puffer Fish (Rare) At the bottom of the B tier is the Puffer Fish. This Rare fish is one of the first upgrades from the common fish you catch at the start of the game. It is found in the Shallow Water and provides a low-to-medium amount of island income. The Puffer Fish is useful for the first 15-30 minutes of gameplay, but you should aim to replace it with Codfish or Colorless Fish as soon as you can afford a better rod.

How to Catch the Rarest Fish

Landing an S-tier fish is not just about luck; it requires preparation. The game's core loop is deceptively simple, but the shark mechanic and distance requirements add layers of strategy.

The Shark Mechanic and Escape

Every time you hook a fish, you trigger the shark. This massive predator will chase you from the point of your catch all the way back to the island. If the shark catches you, you lose the fish you just caught. This means that even if you are lucky enough to hook a Voidfish, you still have to successfully escape. The shark's speed scales with the rarity of the fish, so Secret catches result in the most aggressive chases. Investing in faster rolling (via the gamepass or in-game upgrades) can be the difference between banking a Prism Fish and losing it to the depths.

Far Water Access

The Far Water is the only place where the Voidfish and Alien Fish spawn. To cast into the Far Water, you must purchase enough casting distance training from the island. This requires a substantial amount of in-game cash. A common strategy is to farm Codfish and Dolphins in the Deep Water using a mid-tier rod to fund the expensive distance upgrades. Once you can consistently reach the Far Water, you can finally add the best fish to your collection.

Mutations

Mutations can appear on any fish, drastically increasing their sale value and sometimes their island income. Two mutations have been reported by the community: Bloody and Moon-linked. A fish with a mutation is exponentially more valuable than its normal counterpart. While the x2 Mutation Luck gamepass can help, mutations are still rare. If you catch a mutated Voidfish, it is arguably the most valuable asset in the entire game.

Best Rods and Gamepasses for High-Tier Fishing

Your rod is your most important tool. Rods provide luck multipliers that directly affect the rarity of the fish you hook. While some data is unverified, community consensus points to a clear hierarchy.

The Ice Rod is widely considered the best rod in the game, with an estimated cost of around 50 million cash and a luck multiplier of approximately 2.5x. According to community reports, this is the rod you need to have any realistic chance of catching a Secret fish in the Far Water. The Crow Rod and Thunder Rod are also present in the game, but their stats remain unverified. Until more data is available, saving for the Ice Rod is the safest bet for any serious angler.

Essential Gamepasses

If you are willing to spend Robux, certain gamepasses are more impactful than others. Here is how they rank for high-tier fishing:

The x2 Fish Luck gamepass is the single most powerful purchase you can make. Doubling your luck effectively doubles your chances of rolling a higher rarity fish, making the grind for Secret and Mythic fish significantly less punishing. The x2 Pull Power gamepass is also a strong quality-of-life upgrade, as it helps you reel in fish faster, reducing the window where you might fail the catch. For the best possible setup, combine the Ice Rod with the x2 Fish Luck gamepass.

Progression Guide: From Shallow Water to Secrets

Understanding the fish tier list is one thing, but knowing how to progress through the zones is another. Here is a step-by-step breakdown of how to climb from a basic rod to catching Voidfish.

Phase 1: The Shore (0 - 1M Cash)

Start by fishing in the Shallow Water. Your only goal is to catch Puffer Fish and any common species. Do not worry about escaping the shark perfectly; just get used to the chase mechanic. Sell fish immediately and reinvest all cash into your first rod upgrade and basic training. Avoid saving money early; every dollar should go into improving your catch rate.

Phase 2: Mid Water Mastery (1M - 50M Cash)

Once you can afford a mid-tier rod, move to the Mid Water. Your targets are Codfish and Colorless Fish. These Epic fish will drastically increase your island income. This is the phase where you should start banking fish instead of selling them. A full aquarium of Codfish will generate passive income that snowballs quickly. Stay here until you can afford the Ice Rod. Do not rush to the Deep Water if your rod is weak; you will simply lose fish to the shark and waste time.

Phase 3: Far Water Endgame (50M+ Cash)

After purchasing the Ice Rod for approximately 50 million cash, invest heavily in casting distance training to unlock the Far Water. This is the only zone where Alien Fish and Voidfish spawn. With the Ice Rod's 2.5x luck multiplier, you now have a realistic chance of catching Mythic and Secret fish. At this stage, your island income should be so high that money is no longer a concern. The game becomes a pure hunt for the rarest catches.

FAQ

What is the absolute rarest fish in Pull a Lucky Fish?

The Voidfish is the rarest fish in the game. It is a Secret rarity catch found only in the Far Water. According to community reports, its catch rate is well below 1%, even with the best rod and gamepasses.

How do I unlock the Far Water?

The Far Water is unlocked by purchasing casting distance upgrades on your home island. These upgrades cost a significant amount of in-game cash. You will need a high-tier rod like the Ice Rod and a large income stream from Epic or Legendary fish before you can afford the distance required to cast into it.

Can I get a Voidfish without the x2 Fish Luck gamepass?

Yes, but it is extremely difficult. The x2 Fish Luck gamepass is not required, but it effectively doubles your chances. Without it, catching a Voidfish is estimated to be a <0.5% chance, making it a very long grind.

What does the Bloody mutation do?

The Bloody mutation is a rare visual and economic modifier that can appear on any caught fish. A Bloody fish sells for significantly more cash and generates much higher island income than a standard fish of the same rarity. A Bloody Voidfish is the single most valuable asset in the game.

For more gameplay guides, check out our complete beginners guide. You can also play the game yourself on the official Roblox page.