Tier List

Fish Rarity Tiers

Highest Tier

Secret

Income Impact

Critical

Pull a Lucky Fish fish tier list ranking all catches from Common to Secret rarity. Find the best fish for island income. Updated July 2026.

Fish Rarity Tier Overview

Tier	Rarity	Notable Fish	Income
S	Secret	Voidfish, Prism Fish	Highest
A	Mythic / Legendary	Alien Fish, Dolphin, Sunfish	Very High
B	Epic / Rare	Codfish, Puffer Fish, Colorless Fish	Medium-High
C	Common / Uncommon	Starter fish	Low

Our Pull a Lucky Fish fish tier list ranks every known fish by rarity and estimated island income value. Rankings are based on community data and may shift with game updates. Fish with Secret rarity produce the highest passive island income.

SSecret

Voidfish

Rarest fish — unverified spawn in Far Water

Rarity

Secret

Location

Far Water only

Confidence

Low (community captions)

SSecret

Prism Fish

Tied for rarest with Voidfish

Rarity

Secret

Location

Far Water only

Confidence

Low (community captions)

AMythic

Alien Fish

Second-rarest tier — high island income

Rarity

Mythic

Location

Far Water

Confidence

Low

ALegendary

Dolphin

High-value Legendary fish for island income

Rarity

Legendary

Location

Far Water

Confidence

Medium

BEpic

Codfish

Reliable mid-game fish with decent income

Rarity

Epic

Catch Rate

Higher than Legendary

Best For

Filling island slots early

Core Mechanics

Fish rarity is weighted per cast — each throw has a probability distribution across all rarity tiers. Better rods and higher Fish Luck shift the distribution toward rarer catches. Training casting distance to reach far water is also critical, as the rarest fish are only available in far water zones.

Advantages

Understanding the tier list helps you prioritize which fish to target and which to bank on your island. A single Secret-tier fish can generate more passive income than dozens of Common fish.

Challenges

Data for many fish is unverified. Voidfish, Prism Fish, and Alien Fish existence comes from community captions only. Island income per fish has no confirmed numerical data available.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the rarest fish in Pull a Lucky Fish?+

The Voidfish and Prism Fish are reported as Secret rarity, the highest tier. Their existence is based on community video captions and is unverified.

Does luck affect which fish I catch?+

Yes. Higher Fish Luck and better rods increase your chances of rarer catches. The x2 Fish Luck gamepass doubles your base luck.

Should I bank rare fish on my island?+

Absolutely. Rarer fish generate more passive income per island slot. Prioritize banking your highest-tier catches.

Are the fish stats on this page confirmed?+

Some fish are community-reported and marked as unverified. We clearly label unverified data. Official confirmation from Openwater Games is still pending for many entries.

Quick Tips

💡

Focus on banking S-tier fish first for maximum island income

💡

Train casting distance to reach far water where rare fish live

💡

Use x2 Fish Luck gamepass to shift rarity distribution in your favor

💡

Replace Common fish on your island as you catch higher-tier ones

💡

Protect rare catches from the shark — losing a Secret fish is devastating

⭐ Featured

Pull a Lucky Fish Fish Tier List — Best Catches Ranked by Rarity and Income

Complete fish tier list for Pull a Lucky Fish. All fish ranked from S tier (Secret) to C tier (Common) with rarity, island income value, and catch tips.

Pull a Lucky Fish tier listfish rankingbest fish

Pull a Lucky Fish Secret Fish — How to Catch Voidfish and Prism Fish

Guide to Secret rarity fish in Pull a Lucky Fish. Learn about the Voidfish, Prism Fish, and other ultra-rare catches with unverified community data.

Pull a Lucky Fish secret fishVoidfishPrism Fish rarity

Pull a Lucky Fish Rarity System Explained — From Common to Secret

Deep dive into the Pull a Lucky Fish rarity system. How each rarity tier works, probability per cast, and how luck affects your chances of rare catches.

Pull a Lucky Fish rarityrarity systemprobability rates